Announcements of the IMF's Demise May Prove Premature
Letter to the Editor
September 20, 2006
The timing of Martin Wolf's assertion that the IMF is in financial crisis because of its own success is curious. For it comes at a time when the US economy shows ever-increasing signs of a housing-led slowdown.
It also comes at a time when both oil and non-oil international commodity prices appear to be correcting abruptly from their spectacular run-up over the past three years.
To be sure, since 2002 there has been a marked strengthening in the external positions of many emerging market economies.
However, this improvement would appear to be more a reflection of the favourable external conditions that these countries have enjoyed rather than of the implementation of IMF prescribed policies.
Indeed, a recent IMF study estimates that the substantial run-up in international commodity prices since 2002 has boosted these countries' export earnings by more than a cumulative 20 per cent of their gross domestic product. It remains to be seen how many emerging countries, especially in Latin America, will fare in the event that there is a significant slowing in US economic growth and further sell-off in commodities.
Should that occur, we might find that the many announcements of the IMF's demise were premature.
![]() | |
| Resident Fellow Desmond Lachman |
To be sure, since 2002 there has been a marked strengthening in the external positions of many emerging market economies.
However, this improvement would appear to be more a reflection of the favourable external conditions that these countries have enjoyed rather than of the implementation of IMF prescribed policies.
Indeed, a recent IMF study estimates that the substantial run-up in international commodity prices since 2002 has boosted these countries' export earnings by more than a cumulative 20 per cent of their gross domestic product. It remains to be seen how many emerging countries, especially in Latin America, will fare in the event that there is a significant slowing in US economic growth and further sell-off in commodities.
Should that occur, we might find that the many announcements of the IMF's demise were premature.



