The New Antitrust Paradox
Policy Proliferation in the Global Economy
About This Event

The growth and integration of national and global markets should make the world more competitive. Antitrust policy should become less important. Instead, globalization has produced the opposite result: a veritable antitrust proliferation.

In the United States, the Microsoft case has dramatized the increasingly aggressive antitrust role of state attorneys general. Abroad, more than ninety countries and the European Union now administer competition laws, applying sharply divergent antitrust standards to corporate mergers and other transactions.

The implications for consumer welfare are enormous. Hydra-headed antitrust enforcement is producing serious problems and paradoxes:

  • Business firms need to comply with duplicative and often conflicting legal standards;
  • Extraterritorial antitrust is prone to be used for protectionist--for anticompetitive--purposes;
  • When no jurisdiction can give definitive approval to a transaction or practice and any jurisdiction can exercise a veto, restrictive, interventionist policies will crowd out more liberal policies;
  • Diplomatic misunderstandings and recriminations may contaminate other areas of mutual economic interest.

Possible solutions to these problems range from improved intergovernmental cooperation, to direct policy harmonization (including, within the United States, federal preemption), to a new regime of "structured competition" in antitrust policy modeled on U.S. corporation law.

AEI has called upon leading antitrust scholars, jurists, and practitioners to explore these and other routes to a new and better institutional design for global antitrust.

The conference title consciously echoes The Antitrust Paradox (1978), Robert Bork's landmark contribution to rigorous law-and-economics scholarship on antitrust policy. The same kind of scholarship, which has contributed so much to improving the substance of antitrust policy, may now provide a framework to understand the new problem of proliferating, multi-jurisdictional antitrust regulation.

Agenda
April 21, 2003
1:45 p.m. Registration
2:00 Welcoming Remarks: Michael S. Greve, AEI
Introductory Remarks: Richard A. Epstein, University of Chicago
2:15 Panel I: Antitrust Proliferation
Panelists: William Kovacic, Federal Trade Commission
George L. Priest, Yale Law School
Moderator: Michael S. Greve, AEI
3:45 Break
4:00 Panel II: Vertical Coordination
Panelists: Michael DeBow, Cumberland Law School
William Adkinson, Progress & Freedom Foundation
Moderator: Michael S. Greve, AEI
5:30 Reception
6:30 Dinner
Introduction of Keynote Speaker: Christopher DeMuth, AEI
Keynote Address: Is Federalism Overrated?
Speaker: The Hon. Richard Posner
April 22, 2003
9:00 a.m. Panel III: Central Regimes and Local Monopolies
Panelists: D. Bruce Johnsen and Moin Yahya, George Mason University Law School
Paul B. Stephan, University of Virginia
Moderator: Richard A. Epstein, University of Chicago
10:30 Break
10:45 Panel IV: Neutral Rules or Harmonization?
Panelists: Andrew T. Guzman, Boalt Hall Law School
Michael Trebilcock and Edward Iacobucci, University of Toronto
Moderator: Richard A. Epstein, University of Chicago
12:15 p.m. Lunch
Introduction of speaker: Richard A. Epstein, University of Chicago
Luncheon Address: Cooperation and Convergence in International Antitrust: Why the Light Is Still Yellow
Speaker: The Hon. Diane Wood
2:00 Panel V: International Harmonization or Competition?
Panelists: Wolfgang Kerber and Oliver Budzinski, University of Marburg
John O. McGinnis, Northwestern Law School
Moderator: Michael S. Greve, AEI
3:30 Closing remarks: Richard A. Epstein, University of Chicago
Adjournment
AEI Participants

 

Christopher
DeMuth
  • Christopher DeMuth was president of AEI from December 1986 through December 2008. Previously, he was administrator for information and regulatory affairs in the Office of Management and Budget and executive director of the Presidential Task Force on Regulatory Relief in the Reagan administration; taught economics, law, and regulatory policy at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University; practiced regulatory, antitrust, and general corporate law; and worked on urban and environmental policy in the Nixon White House.

     

  • Phone: 2028625895
    Email: cdemuth@aei.org
  • Assistant Info

    Name: Keriann Hopkins
    Phone: 2028625897
    Email: keriann.hopkins@aei.org

 

Richard
Epstein

 

Michael S.
Greve
AEI on Facebook