About AEI My AEI Support AEI Contact AEI
Home Events Books Short Publications Research Areas Scholars & Fellows


Search


FindAdvanced Search

Browse all short publications by:
- Date
- Subject
- Author
- Type
- Title

SHORT PUBLICATIONS
AEI Newsletter
AEI.org Exclusives
The American
Press Releases
Outlook Series
On the Issues
Papers and Studies
AEI Working Paper Series
Government Testimony
Speeches
Book Reviews
AEI Policy Series
The War on Terror

E-NEWSLETTERS
Enter e-mail:
 

Home >  Short Publications >  World Bank Wasted Money and Lives in Buying Wrong Medicine
World Bank Wasted Money and Lives in Buying Wrong Medicine
Print Mail
Letter to the Editor
By Roger Bate, Amir Attaran
Posted: Thursday, September 13, 2007
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Wall Street Journal  
Publication Date: September 12, 2007

Your editorial "World Bank Corruption" and Bret Stephens's Global View column "Mind the GAP" (both on Sept. 4) expose the myriad illicit practices of some World Bank staff and contractors, particularly in Indian health projects supported by Western taxpayers. The methods used by these bad actors to obfuscate their actions and delay, often permanently, their exposure are interesting. Seventeen months ago we published a paper in The Lancet (a medical journal) about the execrable Indian malaria program of the World Bank, and in particular its purchase in India of chloroquine (CQ), which is ineffective against the fatal form of malaria and was against World Health Organization guidelines. Alternative medicines exist, which are totally effective, but oddly the bank chose not to buy them. We equated this with "medical malpractice."

The bank refused to give us numerous documents on its India malaria project when we were researching the Lancet paper and now we know why--they would have led us to the corruption that permeates the bank's work in India. The internal bank investigation from 2005 that the journal revealed fingers the actions of a firm called Nestor Pharmaceuticals. Available records show that the CQ the bank bought, it bought from Nestor.

Why did the bank ignore WHO's medical advice to avoid CQ, and instead forge ahead to buy this ineffective medicine from a company in India? The bank's investigation alleges Nestor colluded with other suppliers, and manufactured substandard or even chemically diluted medicines.

The bank investigation must continue, and specifically, probe whether corruption underlies the fact the bank bought the wrong medicines, wasting both money and children's lives.

In the Lancet paper we demanded that the bank transfer the funds it devotes to malaria control to an agency better prepared to spend the money effectively--perhaps the President's Malaria Initiative, or the Global Fund for AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria. We see no reason to change that suggestion.

Roger Bate is a resident fellow at AEI. Amir Attaran is a professor at the University of Ottawa.

Related Links
Related article on the quality of malaria drugs by Bate
Related Health Policy Outlook on counterfeit and substandard medicines by Bate and Kathryn Boateng
Related article on substandard malaria drugs by Bate
AEI Print Index No. 22177


Also by Roger Bate
Recent Articles
From Bangkok to the Beltway
Bad Medicine
China's Bad Medicine Is No Game
Latest Book
Making a Killing
The Deadly Implications of the Counterfeit Drug Trade
Economic Outlook

Economic Outlook

In the August issue of Economic Outlook, John H. Makin warns that there is more trouble ahead for the economy.


Real Education
Real Education

In his new book, Real Education: Four Simple Truths for Bringing America's Schools Back to Reality, AEI's Charles Murray focuses on four simple, hard truths that are rarely discussed or even acknowledged by educators and politicians.